Bagel Shop in Warsaw, Indiana
Fresh-baked daily. Flavor-packed. Unapologetically original.
Classic Comfort Meets Fearless Flavor Combinations
Explore Our Bold Bagel Menu
Our menu is designed to surprise and satisfy.
With fresh-baked bagels as the base, we build memorable creations using high quality ingredients, creative toppings, and unexpected twists. Whether you’re in the mood for savory or sweet, you’ll find something worth craving again.
What You’ll Find on the Menu:
Fresh-Baked Bagels
Made daily from scratch in our kitchen.
Decadent Muffins
Options like S’mores, Dirty Chai, and Triple Berry Cheesecake.
Signature Cream Cheeses
Flavors like Garlic Dill Pickle, Kimchi, and Jalapeño Popper.
Savory Muffins
Unique offerings like Sausage Gravy and Meatball Garlic Bread.
Stacked Bagel Sandwiches
Built for breakfast or lunch, full of flavor.
Catering and Preorders
Great for meetings, events, or large pickups.
Fresh, Fun, and Built to Impress
Catering That Brings the Bagel Buzz
Whether you’re feeding a morning meeting, throwing a weekend brunch, or hosting a special event, Lake City Bagels catering brings bold flavor and fresh-baked goodness to the table. We offer flexible options for any group size and occasion, always made with care and creativity.
Boxed Meals
Individually packaged bagel sandwiches and muffins, perfect for meetings or on-the-go events.
Bagel Bars
Build-your-own setups with bagels, cream cheeses, spreads, and toppings—great for interactive group meals.
Bulk Orders
Large-quantity bagels and muffins ready for pickup and perfect for casual gatherings or weekend drop-offs.
Custom Orders
Have something in mind? We’ll work with you to create a spread that fits your event.
Bold Flavors.
Local Love.
Our Story
Real Bagels. No Shortcuts. All Heart.
Lake City Bagels was created to fill a gap in Warsaw—a true stand-alone bagel shop serving fresh, made-from-scratch bagels you can’t get anywhere else nearby.
We’re not here to copy tradition. We’re here to raise the bar with bold flavors, high quality ingredients, and a guest experience that actually means something.
What we Believe
Shawn T. — Customer