About Lake City Bagels

We’re not trying to be the next big franchise or copy what the other guys are doing. In fact, our vision is to be anything but a traditional bagel shop. That’s why we’re the only stand-alone bagel shop within a 30-minute drive, and why our daily menu includes flavors and combinations you may have never seen before.

Think fresh-baked bagels made from scratch every day. Inventive, small-batch cream cheeses like kimchi, jalapeño popper, and garlic dill pickle. Jumbo bagel sandwiches stacked with bold flavor.

And let’s not forget our muffins! These decadent creations can be flavored like s’mores, dirty chai, and savory sausage gravy that taste more like dessert or dinner than a forgettable pastry.

At Lake City Bagels, we don’t compromise on quality, customer service, or creativity. Our bagels are baked fresh daily using high-quality ingredients because you can taste the difference, and we want your experience to be unforgettable from the first hello to the last crumb.

Whether you’re a busy professional grabbing breakfast on the go, a college student fueling up for finals, or a family treating themselves to a weekend bagel spread, we’ve got something special waiting for you.

Our customers don’t just stop by for a bagel. They come to create a food memory. To discover new flavors. To be part of a local spot that feels like it’s truly theirs and part of our community.

We’re on a mission to be the bagel shop you didn’t know you were missing in Warsaw!