Skip to Content

Preorder Bagels & Muffins

Plan Ahead, Pick Up Fresh

Online preordering is coming soon! It’s not available just yet, but we’re getting ready to make ordering your favorite bagels even easier.

Whether you’re feeding your crew at the office, treating your family to a weekend breakfast, or just making sure you actually get your favorite bagel before it sells out, we’ve got you covered. Preorders must be made by 1pm for next day availability and require a minimum order limit.

We ask for at least 24 hours’ notice for bulk orders (six or more) of our full menu offerings. For smaller daily pickup orders, same-day availability may vary based on what’s baking, so order early if you can!

Have Questions? We’re Here for You.

Need help with a custom order? Not sure how many bagels to get for your group? Want to know which muffin pairs best with our blueberry cream cheese? Send us an email with your questions. We love helping fellow food lovers plan the perfect pickup!

lake-city-bagels-photo-48
Fresh Dough.
Bold Flavors.
Local Love.

Why Preorder?

We bake everything fresh each day, and our most popular items go fast. Preordering guarantees that your favorite bagels, muffins, and spreads are reserved just for you. Preordering is also great for:

Bulk orders for team meetings or school runs
Treating yourself or your family to a full dozen
Surprising someone with a bag of baked goodness
When flavors you want aren't available in this week’s menu lineup
lake-city-bagels-photo-20

What You Can Preorder

Bagels by the Dozen – Choose your mix of our fresh-baked bagels
Signature Spreads – From classic cream cheese to bold flavors like kimchi and garlic dill pickle
Jumbo Muffins – Decadent or savory, they’re anything but ordinary
Sandwiches – Breakfast or lunch, bagel sandwiches make a serious meal

How It Works:

Place Your Pre-Order Online

Click below to complete your online order. Choose your items, pickup date, and time.

Order Now

We Bake Fresh Just for You

Every order is made the morning of pickup to ensure peak deliciousness.

Grab & Go or Choose Delivery

Stop by our shop at 2616 Shelden Street, Warsaw, IN, and your order will be packed and ready! Don't have time to stop in? Delivery is also an option.

Ready for Your Bagel Fix?

Whether you’re stopping in, placing a big order, or planning a catered event, Lake City Bagels is here to deliver fresh flavors and unforgettable creations. Come visit us or start your order online today.

Order NowCatering Options

Visit Us 2616 Shelden St • Warsaw, IN 46582

Copyright © 2026, Lake City Bagels, All Rights Reserved.

Website Design by 1Eighty Digital

Make an Order