Preorder Bagels & Muffins
Plan Ahead, Pick Up Fresh
Even if Lake City Bagels is closed, you can still plan ahead! Pre-orders can be placed on Toast any time for an earlier pickup even if we aren’t open.
Simply select your preferred pickup date and time when placing your order through Toast. We’ll have everything ready for you when we reopen!
Whether you’re feeding your crew at the office, treating your family to a weekend breakfast, or just making sure you actually get your favorite bagel before it sells out, we’ve got you covered. Preorders must be made by 1pm for next day availability and require a minimum order limit.
We ask for at least 24 hours’ notice for bulk orders (six or more) of our full menu offerings. For smaller daily pickup orders, same-day availability may vary based on what’s baking, so order early if you can!
Bold Flavors.
Local Love.
Why Preorder?
We bake everything fresh each day, and our most popular items go fast. Preordering guarantees that your favorite bagels, muffins, and spreads are reserved just for you. Preordering is also great for:
