Skip to Content

Location

Plan Your Visit To Lake City Bagels

Lake City Bagels is proud to call Warsaw, Indiana, home. Specifically, the corner of 2616 Shelden Street. Whether you’re a local looking for your morning go-to or just passing through and craving the real-deal bagel experience, our doors are open and the ovens are hot.

2616 Shelden Street
Warsaw, IN 46582

Sun: 8am-1pmMon: ClosedTue-Fri: 7am-2pmSat: 7am-1pm

What To Expect

We’re not your traditional bagel shop. We bake our bagels fresh every morning, serve up bold, creative flavors, and make it our mission to give you the kind of guest service that sticks with you.

Directions & Parking

We’ve got plenty of free parking right out front. Located just minutes from downtown Warsaw and steps from Walmart, we’re easy to access whether you’re on your daily commute or cruising in from a weekend at the lake.

Stay Connected

Follow us on Facebook and Instagram for updates, special flavors, and behind-the-scenes peeks. Have questions before you visit? Reach out through our Contact page, we’d love to hear from you and are happy to help.

Ready for Your Bagel Fix?

Whether you’re stopping in, placing a big order, or planning a catered event, Lake City Bagels is here to deliver fresh flavors and unforgettable creations. Come visit us or start your order online today.

Order NowCatering Options

Visit Us 2616 Shelden St • Warsaw, IN 46582

Copyright © 2026, Lake City Bagels, All Rights Reserved.

Website Design by 1Eighty Digital

Make an Order

Selection of bagels, muffins, and smears arranged on a large wooden cutting board.
Get the Weekly Menu First
Fresh bagels, bold flavors, and promotions, straight to your inbox every week. Sign up now.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.