Catering
Turn Any Gathering Into A Bagel Party
Why Cater With Lake City Bagels?
We’re not your traditional bagel shop, and our catering isn’t traditional either. Every order is made fresh, never frozen, and crafted with care right here in Warsaw. From pillowy-soft bagels to flavorful breakfast and lunch sandwiches, everything we serve is meant to impress.
Need a mix of sweet and savory? Our jumbo muffins are always crowd-pleasers. We’re here to make your life easier and your guests a lot happier!
crave-worthy
bagels & muffins
Events We Cater
What We Offer
Bagel Platters
A beautiful spread of fresh-baked bagels in a variety of flavors, ready to be devoured.
Cream Cheese Flights
From classic to creative (think maple bacon, jalapeno popper, or cucumber dill ), we’ve got the schmear to match.
Bagel Sandwich Boxes
Flavor-packed breakfast and lunch bagel sandwiches, individually wrapped and labeled.
Muffin Trays
Sweet and savory muffin varieties that turn any gathering into a mini brunch party.
Custom Packages
Don’t see exactly what you need? We’re flexible, so let us build your perfect order.
How It Works
Place Order
Place your order online, then we'll confirm details with you.
Fresh-Baked & On-Time
We prep everything the day of your event and have it ready when you need it. Need delivery, set-up, and clean-up options? We can handle that too.