What’s In A Smear? A Look At Our Most Popular Cream Cheese Flavors

A bagel isn’t complete without the perfect smear of cream cheese. At Lake City Bagels, we take pride in crafting rich, flavorful spreads that keep our customers coming back for more.

Whether you’re a traditionalist or someone who loves bold flavor combinations, we’ve got a cream cheese that hits the spot! Let’s take a closer look at some of our most popular flavors.

Classic Plain Cream Cheese

Sometimes, simple is best. Our plain cream cheese is smooth, creamy, and the perfect companion for any bagel. It’s versatile enough to pair with everything from a sourdough bagel to a cinnamon crunch!

Garlic Dill Pickle Cream Cheese

For those who crave something savory, our garlic dill pickle smear packs a bold punch. The tangy pickle flavor blends perfectly with fresh garlic and herbs, creating a spread that’s crisp, zesty, and unforgettable.

It’s a customer favorite on everything bagels and pairs just as well with plain or sourdough.

Roasted Veggie Cream Cheese

Packed with sweet and smoky roasted vegetables, this veggie cream cheese is colorful and delicious. It’s a lighter choice that adds crunch and freshness to your morning or afternoon bagel.

Blueberry Cream Cheese

A little sweet and a little tangy, our blueberry cream cheese is always a hit. It’s especially popular with kids, but adults love it too. Spread it on a plain or sourdough bagel for a sweet start to your day.

Roasted Jalapeño Cream Cheese

If you like a little heat, our jalapeño cream cheese will wake up your taste buds! Creamy, spicy, and full of flavor, it’s the perfect pairing for those who want something bold.

Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cream Cheese

Our brown sugar cinnamon cream cheese is sweet, cozy, and full of warm spice. The rich brown sugar blends with cinnamon to create a smooth, creamy spread that tastes just like comfort in every bite!

Why Our Smears Stand Out

We make our cream cheese spreads fresh with high-quality ingredients. Every batch is blended for the perfect balance of texture and flavor.

When you order a bagel from Lake City Bagels, you know you’re getting a bagel and a smear made with care.

Visit Lake City Bagels Today

Ready to find your new favorite cream cheese flavor?

Stop by Lake City Bagels and try one of our popular smears, or grab a dozen bagels with cream cheese to enjoy at home. We’ll help you discover the perfect pairing for your taste buds.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you make your cream cheese spreads in-house?
Yes, we prepare our cream cheese spreads fresh to ensure the best flavor and quality.

Can I order cream cheese by the tub?
Yes. All of our cream cheese is sold in 3 oz. containers, and you can order as much as you like.

What’s the best bagel to pair with sweet cream cheese?
Plain, sourdough, or cinnamon crunch bagels pair wonderfully with sweet cream cheese flavors like blueberry, brown sugar cinnamon, or strawberry.